They're Real! Máscara de pestanas de volume e alongamento

Bad formula change!!

They must have changed their formula since I last purchased. Mascara ends up all under/around the eye within an hour of application. I'm constantly wiping my under eye. My coworker said it happened to her and several friends too. I will NOT be purchasing again, after being a faithful They're Real user for years!

It smears alot after a long day. Im disappointed they discontinued the primer mascara

Not what it used to be

I used this product for years, but Benefit has reformulated it and it smudges after an hour of wear now. I’ll have to move on -

Normally love but received a dried out one

I LOVE this mascara and never had an issue with it before but this time it dried out within a day or two? Wondering if I received an old sample or something :(

Dried out

I used this for years, daily, but when I got to my second tube in the 2 pack, it was dry. I didnt have it very long, but just over the return time, so I contacted Benefit and they told in other words, too bad. So I found a comparable one that works great. I got that info in a search! Way cheaper too.

Poor performance. Smudges and breaks down.

This product breaks down and left smudges on my lower eyelids. I always needed to wipe my undereye to clean the smudges throughout the day. While I have oily skin, I have never had this issue with a mascara before.

Wanted to love, but didn’t

When I first put this mascara on, I thought it looked great…until about two hours later. Unfortunately it smudges very badly. It was also a nightmare to remove. Glad I bought the mini size.

Super thin, made my lashes fall out. Not really lengthening or voluminous, much better products out there i hate it. can’t do multiple layers or it’ll look like a spider

Awesome beauty

A must have for any occasion, so lengthening and natural looking.

My go to mascara

Love this - great for length. Rich dark black, smooth application, not super wet. I love how the brush fans out my lashes but of course. Easy to use, but obviously application technique matters.

10 years of usage to never again

I had been using this mascara, like a lot of other folks, for over 10 years. From prom, graduation, and everyday makeup- tried and true, I loved it! Since the formula changed a little while ago now I will not be repurchasing again. It left a lot of smudging and completely transferred to the top and bottom of my eyes. I have very hooded eyes, so finding a mascara that does not smudge is really important- and sadly, this one now smudges a lot.

Catastrophique

J’avais l’habitude de prendre ce mascara et bizarrement le mascara s’effrite rend les cils mousseux un résultat catastrophique. Le rendu est horrible on a l’impression que j’ai appliqué un mascara sec . Je ne le racheterais plus jamais