Colorgraph Crayon - Eyeliner

Junk eyeliners

This was by far then worst overpriced luxury junk. Horrible eyeliners, I threw them in the trash..

Best Pencil Ever!

This eyeliner is stellar! It’s very buildable and can go from natural and delicate, just on the top waterline to dramatic easily. Unlike some pencils, it’s very gentle and non-irritating on the eyes.

Dramatic cat eye

I can create a dramatic cat eye with the Valentino Gel Eyeliner Pencil. The application process is flawless and delivers a perfect line without smudging or lack of color. I remove the eyeliner with oil based eye makeup remover with ease and then using warm water and a makeup remover towel by holding over my eyes for 30 seconds.

Perfection!

Best eyeliner I’ve found since my former holy grail was discontinued in 2021 (iykyk). Valentino NAILED IT with these, they are absolutely worth the money! They apply effortlessly…not so soft they break or smush, but not hard either. There is no tugging or feathering and the pigment is wonderful. I’m 47 and perimenopausal, so I battle bouts of hot flashes/sweats/tears often and in my experience these don’t migrate, bleed, or transfer once they set. I don’t get any fallout or flecking, they stay put till I wash my face at night. Another bonus is: the brush on the opposite end is actually functional, perfect for blending and smudging while still being gentle on the delicate eye area. Very well designed and thought out. My only wish is, for the price a sharpener would’ve been nice, but I’m still not mad over it ;)

Do not buy!

I have never had an eyeliner break apart. I have ordered 2, and they are unusable. A very defective product for The price. I didn’t even get 1 use out of the pencils!

Fabulous in every way: beautiful colors, applying.

Fabulous colors and stays on. I LOVE. THIS. PENCIL!! My eyes are sensitive and I worry about wearing anything on my eyes. The Valentino pencil works really well.

Mildly disappointing

I am so so bummed. The color is amazing and I love the brush on the end but this liner completely dried out on me within two months. Even with gentle heat it tugged when I tried to salvage it :(

🌊 Bold, Long-Lasting & Absolutely Stunning! 💙✨

The Valentino Colorgraph Eyeliner in Magnet Blue truly impressed me from the very first use. The quality is outstanding, the pigment is bold, vibrant, and instantly elevates any look while still feeling elegant. What I love most is how easy it is to apply. The formula glides on smoothly and allows for both precise thin lines and more dramatic styles without any effort. But the best part for me is that it’s a water-based eyeliner with incredible staying power. It doesn’t smudge or transfer and lasts all day long. This is a game changer, because my eyes often water when I wear makeup, and most products end up ruined. With this eyeliner, even when my eyes tear up, my look stays flawless. In short, this is a product of excellent quality, gorgeous color, and unbeatable wear. It has quickly become one of my must-haves, and I highly recommend it! 💙✨

Didn't smudge all day!

I absolutely love the Valentino Colorgrah Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil! The texture is creamy and glides on effortlessly without tugging at my skin. The shade Brown Fondant is the perfect deep navy shimmer — it gives my eyes definition while still adding a fun pop of color. I wore it all day and it didn’t smudge or transfer, even through humidity. The built-in brush is a great bonus for blending out the liner into a softer, smoky look. I’ve tried many eyeliners, but this one feels luxe and stays put like no other. Highly recommend if you want something long-lasting and bold!

NOT a waterproof

It is NOT a waterproof pencil as marketed. It fades in a couple of hours. I had higher expectations considering price and brand.

Intense black,and long ladting

I really loved the formula it definitely last long, I prefer gel liners. It was easy to take off with a makeup balm remover. I love it and will repurchase. The pigment was a great dark black loved it.

This IS IT for your waterline. Run don't walk!

This stuff does NOT transfer out of your waterline at all. I have tried about 20 liners that were all highly rated for the waterline and all failed. This one IS A WINNER!!! FINALLY I can tightline without it transferring all over the lower waterline. The price is my only complaint but the product is 10 out of 5! Get it!